Display Conference Proceedings


Conference Proceedings 1998


Remove Abstracts

Title
Title pages: Volume 2
 
Content
 
Preface
Preface
Clive Kanes
 
List of Reviewers
Referees for MERGA 21 Published Papers
 
Keynote Address
I keep six honest serving men 87527 downloads
Peter Galbraith

No abstract available.

The 3 Rs in new times: Research, rhetoric, and reality 87529 downloads
Lyn D. English

In this paper I argue that we need to analyse critically our currently popular theories of mathematical learning and instruction. I initially raise a number of issues warranting attention and begin by reviewing briefly a selection of theories, confining my discussion to socioconstructivist perspectives, situated cognition, and cognitive psychology science. I then undertake a critical analysis of these theories, with a focus on the curriculum examples that have been used to support these theories. Finally, I propose a working model that might assist us in advancing mathematics education and research into new times.

The intension/intention of teaching mathematics 87528 downloads
Stephen Lerman

In recent years mathematics educators have begun to draw on academic disciplines beyond mathematics and traditional, cognitive psychology as resources for theorising. Sociology, anthropology, and even psychoanalysis have formed the theoretical framework for some researchers. Mathematics education has become more conscious of culture, in all sorts of ways. But in cultural studies, writers have been addressing what it is to be and to communicate, and therefore to learn and to teach, in ways which of most of us in mathematics education have not been aware. In this paper I attempt to examine and use postmodem ideas to look, in particular, at mathematics teaching.

 
Practical Implication Award
 
Symposium
 
Research Paper
Title pages: Volume 1 87528 downloads
One Teacher's Problem Solving Beliefs and Practices: Influences and Coherence 87527 downloads
Judy Anderson

This study explores the sources of influence on and the level of coherence of one teacher's beliefs and practices in relation to mathematical problem solving. Rose regularly uses problem solving approaches in her Year 2 class as she believes that this makes mathematics learning meaningful. Her beliefs and practices have been strongly influenced by her own experiences as a learner of mathematics as well as by advice received in postgraduate education and in curriculum documentation. Her beliefs are coherent when explored using a variety of data collection methods.

Towards the Study of the Processes and Effects of Internationalisation in Mathematics Education 87531 downloads
Bill Atweh, Philip Clarkson, & John Malone

This proposed study is designed to investigate a rapidly expanding area of activity in mathematics education that has not been researched and theorised. Arguably, mathematics education is one of the most internationalised areas of the curriculum. TIlls paper outlines a longitudinal study to investigate issues in the internationalisation and globalisation of mathematics education in 3 regions with ties to Australia. It is a part of a workshop that aims to obtain feedback from peers and trial the instruments to be used.

The Use of Action Research To Assist the Transition into Teaching 87529 downloads
Bill Atweh and Ann Heirdsfield

This paper discusses the learning's from an action research project conducted in collaboration between beginning teachers and a group of university researchers in mathematics and science education. Participants formed action research cells based on their common interests. This paper presents the overall structure of the project and discusses the resulting benefits to the participants and the benefits and . limitations of the use of action research to assist transition into teaching.

THE EFFECTIVENESS OF A NO-GOAL APPROACH IN SOLVING PYTHAGOREAN 2-STAGE PROBLEMS 87531 downloads
Paul Ayres

Four groups of Year-8 students completed a set of 2-stage Pythagorean problems under differing conditions. One group completed the set with specific goals (find x) without instruction; the second and third groups were encouraged to either work forwards or backwards from the goal (x); whereas, the fourth group completed the set with unspecified goals (no x's). On a subsequent set of test problems, the no-goal group demonstrated a superior performance than the other groups in applying Pythagoras' Theorem.

FACTORS INFLUENCING PREDICTIONS ABOUT RANDOMLY GENERATED SEQUENCES 87526 downloads
Paul Ayres & Jenni Way

The detailed analysis of four probability experiments conducted with Grade 5 and 6 students revealed trends and patterns in both the group and individual data. These results suggested that certain variables in the experiments, such as particular sequences of outcomes and the confirmation/refutation of student predictions, influenced the students' decision making strategies. The use of video recordings of deliberately controlled probability experiments offers the potential to systematically explore these influential factors with large samples of students.

Towards a framework for analysing power relationships in small group discussions 87528 downloads
Mary Barnes

Based on an approach to power derived from the work of Michel Foucault, this paper describes the development of a framework for analysing power relationships in small groups of students working on collaborative activities. Student-student interactions were observed, videotaped and transcribed. Key features that emerged were techniques used to control the flow of the discourse in the group and behaviours which influenced the mathematical knowledge constructed. Other factors include body language and the control of resources.

Year 5 students' available and accessible knowledge of decimal-number numeration 87534 downloads
Annette R. Baturo

This paper reports on a study of the decimal-number numeration knowledge held by 112 Year 5 students who had completed formal instruction in tenths and hundredths. It explores the interaction between available and accessible place-value and regrouping knowledge. Available knowledge was elicited through diagnostic test items; accessible knowledge was elicited through an error analysis of the students' numeration procedures used in addition and subtraction algorithms. The results showed that performance varied markedly between classes (indicating an instructional effect), that regrouping was more difficult than place value, and that there was generally a direct relationship between available and accessible knowledge (although there were many instances of high-available and low-accessible knowledge).

Mathematics curriculum and development 87529 downloads
Andy Begg

This paper explores curriculum development issues in nine regions in five federal countries. The focus is on the curriculum contents, the development process, and the role of teachers in development. The study explores alternatives that others may consider when reviewing their curriculum.

The Impact of an Early Number Project on the Professional Development of Teachers 87528 downloads
Janette Bobis & Peter Gould

This paper reports the findings of an investigation that evaluated the impact of the Early Number Project conducted by the NSW Department of School Education in 1996. It includes information obtained from a questionnaire distributed to all participating classroom teachers. Generally teachers benefited from their involvement in the project both professionally and personally. The classroom-based model of professional development was determined to be a major factor in the success of the project.

Arithmetic, pre-algebra, and algebra: a model of transition 87540 downloads
Boulton-Lewis, G.M., Cooper, T., Pillay, H., and Wilss, L

Learning to operate algebraically requires assimilation of new mathematical concepts and procedures. Current literature identified a gap between arithmetic and algebra and proposed a pre-algebra level. This paper reports on a longitudinal study that investigated students' readiness for algebra, from a cognitive perspective, to determine what constitutes a pre-algebraic level of understanding. Thirty-three students in grades 7,8, and 9 participated. A two-path model depicts the transition from arithmetic to pre-algebra to algebra; students' understanding of relevant knowledge is discussed.

The invisible wall project: problem solving processes of pupils who work on problems with a goal which can not be reached 87529 downloads
Birgit Burchartz & Martin Stein

The invisible wall project analyses problem solving processes of children in grades 3-4 and 8- 9. By now, we have transcribed more than 160 interviews; as a consequence, the qualitative interpretive methods were complemented by quantitative methods. Besides analysis of difficulty of tasks and learning while being tested, we describe the process of problem solving by action profiles. Using the method of divergent coding, we introduce interpretive methods to better understand action profiles.

"Why are we assessed in mathematics?": The views of students 87529 downloads
Ken C. Carr

Students from elementary, intermediate and high schools were asked why they considered they were assessed in mathematics. The small sample (n=559) came from the US, the Netherlands, and New Zealand. Some responses were consistent across countries. Most students thought they were assessed in order that teachers might find out what they know/understand. Some cultural differences are suggested by the data illustrative comments are included.

Developing a framework for viewing affective and knowledge factors in teaching primary mathematics 87528 downloads
Jean Carroll

An extensive study of the literature on teachers' views of mathematics and mathematics teaching revealed inadequacies in the available frameworks for structuring and reporting on research. In this paper a new framework is developed for analysing and describing primary school teachers' knowledge and feelings about mathematics teaching and learning. The framework; 'Teacher Type Table', was developed after surveying 107 primary school teachers in suburban Melbourne. The teacher type table is presented here as a model for use in the professional development of teachers.

Teachers' understandings of the role of learning activities 87528 downloads
Min-Pyng Chen

This study investigated teachers' understandings of the role of learning activities in secondary school mathematics. A qualitative study involving interviews and questionnaires was conducted in government and non-government schools. Most teachers in the study were supportive of the use of learning activities in the classroom for both teaching and learning purposes but were aware of constraints of time, adequate resources and curriculum requirements.

Showing and telling: Primary students' outcomes in data representation and interpretation 87531 downloads
Helen L. Chick and Jane M. Watson

Students, in triads in a near-classroom environment, were video-taped as they worked on interpreting and representing supplied data. Their responses were categorised using the SOLO taxonomy. Representation skills varied from copying out some of the data to relating two variables graphically; interpretation skills varied similarly. Moreover, there appeared to be connections between the two skills. The study also considered the nature and effectiveness of the collaboration which took place within groups.

Representing the connectedness of mathematical knowledge 87529 downloads
Mohan Chinnapan , Michael Lawson and Rod Nason

An important area of mathematics teachers' expertise is their content knowledge. One way to characterise the quality if this knowledge is to examine the organisation of the various components that form the content knowledge base. In this paper we describe the procedures we have used to generate estimates of the state of connectedness of mathematical knowledge of teachers. We illustrate the procedures by focusing on a single teacher's knowledge of the concept of square.

Beginning teachers' problems with fundamental mathematics 87526 downloads
P C Clarkson

A, Ministerial Report has questioned again whether beginning teachers are adequately prepared at universities. The Report proposes measures to ensure this does happen such as a testing regime in mathematics and literacy at the completion of courses. This paper provides data that indicates some beginning teachers do not show competence in the mathematics they will soon be teaching. Hence there is a basis for concerns raised in the Ministerial Report. However it is argued that the solutions in the Report are somewhat naive and an inadequate response to this problem.

Investigating students' understanding of the relationships among quadrilaterals 87528 downloads
Penelope Currie and John Pegg

This study is the second in a series designed to explore how class inclusion concepts evolve. Class inclusion concepts in this context is the ability to have an overview of possible relationships that exist among figures, and is an important characteristic of Level 3 thinking in the van Hiele Theory. In depth interactive interviews were undertaken with 24 capable secondary students concerning how they view linkages among six different quadrilaterals. A developmental pattern is identified.

Rethinking what it means to understand: the case of combinatorial problem solving 87543 downloads
Lyn D.English

This paper argues for the need to address children's structural understanding in dealing with mathematical problems. In support of this argument, a study that investigated children's structural understanding of 2- D and 3-D combinatorial problems, via a range of thought-revealing tasks, is reported. The results raise a number of issues for further attention, including the discrepancy between children's accuracy and their structural understanding, and the lack of significant correlation between children's graphic and symbolic representations on most of the problems. Individual profiles of response highlight the importance of rethinking our interpretations of understanding.

New times for mathematics in vocational education and training 87529 downloads
Gail E. FitzSimons

This paper explores some of the effects on mathematics education in the VET sector where economic rationalist ideologies prevail, and hegemonic industrial values subsume educational values. In a sector which carries considerable investment of public and private funding; it may be expected that mathematics, which has a high public profile generally and with sections of business and industry in particular, should be an important focus. Somewhat paradoxically, there is an apparent lack of status.

Exploring avenues of reflective practice with pre-service Mathematics teachers 87529 downloads
Sandra Frid, Ted Redden, Chris Reading

Pre-service teachers participated in peer and self assessment activities during a seminar series focused on current issues in mathematics education. Their feedback comments to each other and the various assessment forms they used were analysed to determine what changes took place in what they perceived to be important issues, how the quality of their comments changed over time, what they felt they learned from peer and self assessment, and how they developed in their capacity to reflect critically.

Identifying the Dilemmas in Early Mathematics Teaching 87528 downloads
Ann Gervasoni

This study gathered teachers' descriptions of dilemmas they faced when teaching young children mathematics. It was considered that asking teachers to describe teaching dilemmas would enable them to identify a problematic aspect of their teaching practice, and lead to reflection, evaluation and refinement of their practice so that their students' mathematical learning would be more powerful. In analysing the dilemmas described by teachers, key elements were identified. These elements have important implications for providing effective professional development.

"I don't know if I'm doing it right or I'm doing it wrong!" Unresolved uncertainty in the collaborative learning of mathematics 87527 downloads
Merrilyn Goos

This paper reports on a study which investigated patterns of collaborative metacognitive activity in senior secondary school classrooms. Although peers working together on mathematical tasks may enjoy the metacognitive benefits of being able to monitor and regulate each other's thinking, collaboration does not guarantee that they will achieve a mathematically productive outcome. Analysis of a videotaped lesson transcript illustrates how metacognitive uncertainty, itself a trigger for collaboration, remained unresolved when students did not have the means of validating their solution.

Visual reasoning and teaching styles in mathematics classrooms 87529 downloads
Kevin Hannah

Four mathematics teachers with different preferences for the use of visual strategies in solving problems are compared in their use and support of visual methods in their classrooms. Presmeg (1985) found that no teacher who displayed a strong preference for non-visual strategies in problem solving made substantial use of visual methods in their classroom. In this study, the teacher who least preferred to use visual strategies to solve problems displayed a strong use of visual methods in the classroom.

Flexible/inflexible: Clare and Mandy's story 87529 downloads
Ann M. Heirdsfield

Research has shown that mental computation is a valid computational method which contributes to mathematical thinking as a whole (e.g., Sowder, 1990). This paper reports on a pilot study of young children's understanding of mental computation, and compares the mental architecture of two mental computers, one flexible and one inflexible. Further questions which have been raised as a result of this pilot study will also be discussed.

We really put our minds to it: Cognitive engagement in the mathematics classroom 87529 downloads
Sue Helme and David Clarke

This paper reports the analysis of videotape and interview data from four year 8 mathematics lessons from the perspective of student cognitive engagement. The study attempted to contribute to our understanding of cognitive engagement by locating empirical evidence for its occurrence within the classroom. On the basis of the data we have examined, cognitive engagement can be consistently recognised by specific linguistic and behavioural indicators and appears to be promoted by particular aspects of the classroom situation, the task, and the individual.

Maori mathematics education: The challenge of providing immersion programmes for preservice Maori primary teachers 87529 downloads
Leeana Herewini

With the rapid growth of Maori language schooling in New Zealand in recent years, and the development of a Maori mathematics curriculum, there has been considerable demand for Maori primary teachers who are both fluent in Maori and competent in teaching mathematics. Trying to meet this demand has proved a real challenge. This paper outlines and discusses a number of factors faced by Maori mathematics teacher educators in preparing preservice Maori teachers for the primary classroom.

Towards an explanation of curriculum control 87527 downloads
John Horwood

The Mathematics curriculum has undergone extensive change over the past few years and much attention has been directed towards coping with the demands of this change. However curriculum has social implications and it is important to examine the intentions of curriculum innovation, which, in turn, leads us to consider the issue of control of the curriculum. This paper draws on the work of Max Weber as it attempts to fashion an explanatory model that will provide a conceptual framework for the consideration of curriculum change within the context of curriculum control.

How sixth grade students explain connections between common and decimal fractions 87530 downloads
Robert P. Hunting, Lauren M. Oppenheimer, Catherine S. Pearn, Eroia Nugent

Sixth grade students' responses to a task which involved matching common fractions and decimal fractions were examined. Of interest was their understanding of relationships between these symbolic forms, evidenced in explanations offered in an interview setting, and the role of the follow-up question in helping them express their thinking. A most favored explanation involved relating decimal and common fractions to a unit of 100.

Mathematics curriculum change in the northern territory: What do teachers really think? 87529 downloads
Rosemary Jacoh & Sandra Frid

Northern Territory secondary teachers' awareness of curriculum change in mathematics and their thoughts on its impact upon teaching and learning are reported. A survey followed by semi-structured, in-depth interviews were used for data collection and analysis was done inductively. Teachers were aware of a number of changes and expressed many concerns about their impact, especially in relation to appropriate in-service opportunities. Discussion of findings in relation to geographical, educational and cultural features of the NT is included.

The effective use of calculators in the teaching of numeracy 87527 downloads
Sonia Tones and Howard Tanner

Current debates about numeracy in the UK focus on the availability of calculators but although standards of numeracy are poor, they have not changed significantly since pre-calculator days. It is the way numeracy is taught which is the problem, with or without calculators. Effective use of calculators should be associated with the concurrent development of students' number sense and mental methods. Calculators can enhance the teaching and learning of mathematics if used as a focus for discussion and reflection on learning.

New knowledge/new teachers/new times: How processes of subjectification undermine the implementation of investigatory approaches to teaching mathematics. 87526 downloads
Mary Klein

The research presented in this paper confronts head on the difficult question of teacher change. It was catried out with preservice teachers in a mathematics methods course in the second year of their teacher education program. Collected data reveal how students' prior experiences of institutionalised mathematics reveal patterns of subjectification which actively undermine the future implementation of more investigatory methods of teaching. I use the poststructuralist concepts of knowledge, positioning and subjectivity: initially as analytic tools to expose the coercive operation of the mathematics discourse; and collectively, as a conceptual base from which to think about possibilities for change.

Affective factors and the improvement of algebraic problem solving 87529 downloads
Saraswathi Kota and Mike Thomas

Problem solving is an important activity in algebra, as all mathematics, and research has shown that affective factors can be crucial to mathematical progress. This research study considered 105 15 year old students, and investigated the relationship between their affective domain and algebraic problem solving ability. Analysing students performing at different ability levels, our test and interview data have enabled us to describe a preliminary model of the interaction between self-concept, self-perception, enjoyment, interest, motivation, anxiety and problem solving ability, describing how they may be influencing students' learning.

Tertiary mathematics: Perceptions of schoolleavers and mature-age students 87527 downloads
Gilah C. Leder & Helen J. Forgasz

As part of a study focusing on mature age students in tertiary mathematics courses, a survey was administered to a large number of fIrst year mathematics students. Data on personal background, self-perceptions as learners of mathematics and perceptions of the tertiary learning environment were gathered. Responses from school leavers and mature age students were compared. Differences were found on several background factors and some students! attitudes and beliefs. Generally, the mature age students were more satisfIed with the tertiary learning environment.

Using technology to enhance children's spatial sense 87527 downloads
Tom Lowrie

This paper examines the way in which two young children engage in a computer-based problem solving activity that required a degree of visual-spatial reasoning. The case study traces the children's spatial-visual understandings and looks at the way in which these understandings were activated and developed through the particular activity.

Pre-service teachers' understandings of word problems 87529 downloads
Kevin J. Maguire

Mathematics curricular statements refer to problem solving, in particular word problems, as a means of relating the curriculum to "reality". Research indicates that pre-service primary teachers have little knowledge of woro problems despite the strong emphasis on their importance within the curriculum. This study reports on the understandings of word problems types of pre-service primary teachers. A number of activities were given as part of a mathematics education method course. Educational implications of these findings are discussed and recommendations proffered as to the amelioration this situation.

Protasis: A technique for fostering professional development 87526 downloads
John Mason

The tenn protasis is used to describe an epigrammatic expression which, in an appropriate context, stimulates questioning of assumptions and behaviour. By extension, the word protasis is applied to a disciplined technique for fostering professional development through the use of protases, and a theory is put forward of when and why protasic techniques work.

Towards a psychology of knowing-to 87530 downloads
.lohn Mason and Mary Spence

While considerable attention has been focused on forms of teacher knowledge (eg. Shulman, Elbaz, Petersen, Carpenter et al) as essential components of expert and effective teaching, but knowing-that, knowing-how, and knowingwhy are insufficient to enable a teacher to act upon that knowledge. What is critical is that teachers know-to act in the moment-by-moment unfolding of a mathematics lesson. We distinguish different types of knowing, and following Gattegno, relate these to levels of awareness. Our methods use descriptions and illustrations such as a fine-grained study of one teacher involved with innovative materials for teaching algebra to 13 year-olds to help the reader experience distinctions which we have found fruitful. Furthermore, the situation is self-referent, for what we want children to learn is to to know-to act themselves when formulating or solving problems. Drawing on the study, on our experience, and on the experience of others, we move towards a psychology of how knowing-to arises and can be supported.

School-based assessment in VCE Mathematics: Ten years on 87526 downloads
Barry McCrae, John Dowsey, Max Stephens

Since the introductio'n of the Victorian Certificate of Education in 1989, assessment in VCE mathematics subjects has included school-based tasks undertaken over an extended period of time. This paper reports on an evaluation of the latest of many changes that have been made to these tasks since their introduction and examines whether they have retained their validity for assessing problem solving and investigative project work. Student use of powerful technology is identified as an emerging issue in their future conduct.

A new trilemma 87527 downloads
D.F. (Mac) McKenzie

One perennial unanswered question for debate among mathematics educators is that of 'What is mathematics?'. Polarised views range from those who point to traditional classical Euro-centric knowledge as the definitive answer to those who wish to widen the definition to include mathematics from every instance of mathematical activity. This paper explores the dilemma thus raised and suggests that the inclusion of a third element may help to clarify the issue.

Teachers interpreting algebra: Teachers' views about the nature of algebra 87528 downloads
Brenda Menzel and David Clarke

This paper looks at the different ways teachers interpreted and represented algebra for their students. In this study, teachers are viewed as mediating between the student and the mathematics content. The teachers in this study differed widely in their epistemological and pedagogical beliefs about algebra but tended to teach similar content. The results of this study suggest that teachers' choices are a consequence of particular beliefs about algebra and that these beliefs are attributable to cultural influences rather than academic considerations.

Long Odds: Longitudinal Development of Student Understanding of Odds 87529 downloads
.Jonathan B. Moritz

Student understanding of odds is explored by analysis of response data collected in 1993, 1995 and 1997. Students were asked to interpret a newspaper headline, "North at 7-2". Responses included interpreting the numbers as the score, and in three contexts of expression involving chance, frequency of wins, and betting. Levels of responses were assigned according to the SOLO developmental model. Longitudinal development for individuals was observed, and females tended to interpret the numbers as the score, while males were more likely to respond in the context of chance or betting. Levels of response from Grade 6 and 9 students in 1995 and 1997 were lower than in 1993.

An arithmetic game with strategic components - playing procedures of primary school children 87527 downloads
Doris Mosel-Gobel

The project children playing arithmetic games with strategic components concerns with. the existence and with types of strategies used during playing. In a qualitative study with an interpretive background we have observed primary school children of different grades playing arithmetic games with strategic components. In this paper we shall present in detail the procedure of children of grade 3 playing an addition-game with strategic character.

Ability Grouping: Some Implications for Building Mathematical Understanding 87529 downloads
Judith A. Mousley

In response to an interview question on features of classroom organisation that support the development of mathematical understanding, all four teachers interviewed referred to the benefits of "ability grouping". This was seen as a means of structuring learning conditions so that teachers could attend to children with similar levels of understanding. Subsequently, achievement grouped classes were videotaped. Analysis of the data showed that interactions within this mode of organisation demonstrated the same problematic features as whole-class teaching. It is concluded that if achievement grouping is to be used, other strategies need to be used to make mathematics pedagogy inclusive.

Ethnographic Research in Mathematics Education: Using Different Types of Visual Data Refined from Videotapes 87528 downloads
Judith A. MousIey

Some ethnomethodological research techniques that can be used to analyse social activity in mathematics classrooms are examined. A method where sections of video-audio tapes were transcribed to facilitate detailed inquiry, and individual "photographs" were used to reproduce some of the data not available in transcriptions, is described. Snippets of the original data were also available in movie format. This paper outlines some of the advantages and limitations of each of these three forms of visual data, and raises issues of anonymity and subjectivity. Ethnography

A research-based framework for assessing early multiplication and division strategies 87530 downloads
Joanne T. Mulligan

This paper describes the integration of multiplication and division strategies within a research-based Learning Framework in Number (NSW Department of Education and Training, 1998). The framework, consisting of six levels of multiplication and division knowledge is described in order of increasing sophistication of modelling, counting, grouping and sharing processes. Assessment tasks show a progression from initial grouping and counting to abstract composite units, to repeated addition and subtraction and to multiplication and division as operations. The framework, which is integral to the Count Me In Too Project is currently being implemented in years K-2 in NSW schools.

A graphical approach to the teaching of introductory calculus 87527 downloads
Bruce Nevill, & John Wycliffe

This research project investigated the use of computer software (ANUgraph) in the development of calculus concepts. One group of students completed the calculus unit following a traditional teacher-exposition method. The other group covered the same content using a graphical approach, which relied heavily upon the use of the computer software to introduce and reinforce key concepts. Results indicate that the lessons proved successful in increasing students' understanding of the fundamental concepts of calculus.

Children's matching of melodies and line graphs 87529 downloads
Steven Nisbet and John Bain

Children (1 0-11 years) were asked to match short melodies and line graphs. Evidence was found for significant visual/graphical influences in the matching process (as well as previously established melodic factors). Intramodal tasks were performed better than cross-modal task, and within those categories, visual first items were performed better than melody-first items. Mathematics ability was a significant main effect, but evidence pointed towards an effect of mathematics experience more than aptitude. Musical ability had only a limited effect.

Identifying Separate and Connected Knowing in Mathematics Education 87530 downloads
Jude Ocean

This paper describes the development of a questionnaire to identify Separate and Connected Knowers (Belenky, Goldberger, Clinchy and Tarule (1986) in mathematics. Justification for the selection of items is provided from the work of Belenky et aI (1986), Buerk (1985), Becker (1995, 1996), Koch (1996), and Erchick (1996). The questionnaire was administered to 67 university students as part of a larger study. Interviews within the main study showed that the questionnaire had served its purpose; it had accurately identified a group of Separate Knowers in mathematics.

Developing the angle concept through investigations 87534 downloads
Kay Owens

Children in Year 2 and 4 were developing the concept of angle through their responsiveness, manipulating of materials, and interactions with others. Their selective attention to aspects of the materials, interactions, or their own imagery and thinking assisted the development of the concept.

Is there a need for a Mathematics Intervention program in Grades 3 and 4? 87527 downloads
Catherine Pearn

The standard of numeracy skills of young Australians continues to be of concern to mathematics educators. teachers. parents and politicians. This paper discusses whether a mathematics intervention program developed for Grade 1 warrants extension into Grades 3 and 4. The focus is on 1997 data that show that although Grade 3 and 4 students had made significant progress since Grade 1. there is still need for additional assistance in Grades 3 and 4.

Year 3 students' place-value misconceptions: Another look at MAB 87564 downloads
Peter S. Price

Sixteen Year 3 students were interviewed individually about two- and threedigit numeration concepts, before and after ten groupwork sessions. One group of questions asked students about values represented by each digit in a two-digit number. Responses revealed that some students had not developed the idea that the "tens" digit represents a collection of ones, but believed that it represented only its face value. Comparison of results before and after the group work sessions showed that a number of participants had improved understandings of values represented by individual digits at the conclusion of the study. These results have implications for how place-value concepts are developed with place-value blocks.

Teaching mathe.matically gifted students in primary school 87530 downloads
lan Putt

The paper examines the changing conception of giftedness over the last four decades, and characteristics of mathematically gifted students. Ways of identifying mathematically gifted students in a study conducted with year 6 students are described. The Renzulli Enrichment Triad model for catering for gifted students is outlined. Case studies of a number of school and individual teacher's programs which cater for mathematically gifted students are described. A professional development module [CD ROM] designed for teacher inservice will be demonstrated.

Orchestrating Different Voices in Student Talk about Infinity: Theoretical and Empirical Analyses 87529 downloads
Peter D Renshaw and Raymond A J Brown

In this paper we review major theoretical perspectives on differences between students in their thinking and classroom talk, and conclude that Bakhtin's concept of voice provides a powerful way of theorising difference that draws attention to the multivoca1ity (inherent diversity) of individual ideas and utterances. It is the orchestration of the diversity of voices that enables new insights to emerge both collectively and individually. We apply analytical tools (derived from Bakhtin) to an episode of collective argumentation focussed on the concept of infinity, and we identify key elements of everyday classroom practice that enable challenging and productive talk to occur.

Measuring Attitudes towards Mathematics in Early Childhood and Primary Teacher Education 87527 downloads
Carolyn Roberts, Patricia Cretchley, Chris Harman

Changes in attitude have been measured over a semester of mathematics in the fIrst year of Early Childhood and Primary teacher training. The unit of study is not a curriculum unit, is taught by mathematicians and explores mathematical ideas and experiences. The Fennema-Shennan Attitudes Scale was used to measure changes in confidence, effectance motivation, and usefulness. Analysis of the results indicates a challenging outcome - the only signifIcant change was a drop in their perception of the usefulness of mathematics.

A Survey of Graphics Calculator Use in Victorian Secondary Schools 87527 downloads
AlIa Routitsky and Patrick Tobin

In 1997, Victoria became the first state to permit the use of graphics calculators in final external examinations. The action was seen as radical for both social and educational reasons. Concerns were raised about the propriety of using the calculators and whether their use would add to existing educational disparities. With the support of the Board of Studies, a survey of secondary schools was undertaken to gauge the response to this decision and inform further action on graphics calculator use in mathematics courses.

The Search for Pattern: Student Understanding of the Table of Values Representation for Function 87529 downloads
Julie Ryan and Julian WilIiams

This study explores student understanding of the table of values representation for the function concept. One hundred and seventy eight students in Years 8, 9 and 10 across three schools in Melbourne undertook two pen-and-paper tests which sought to uncover the nature of the links students made between different representational forms for function. For the table of values representation there are many students who are operating in an arithmetic or pre-algebraic frame across the three year levels. There are low levels of response for algebraic patterning and indications that most students are at a rhetorical or syncopated stage of symbolism.

Parent Newsletters supporting Mathematics in the Junior Primary School 87528 downloads
Jan Savell

This paper presents research into the effect newsletters had on parental perceptions of junior school mathematics. Information on classroom content allowed parents to recognise and individualise mathematics that occurred spontaneously in the home. Interviews of parents and teachers revealed discrepancies in the way mathematics was viewed. All the teachers and participating parents were positive about the benefits of the newsletters.

Challenging beliefs about mathematics learning and teaching using an electronic learning community 87527 downloads
Sandy Schuck and Gerry Foley

Prospective primary school teachers often see mathematics as a rigid, inaccessible subject. Their fixed ideas about the nature of mathematics can often impede their learning, and future teaching. This paper investigates a web-based intervention which encouraged dialogue about mathematics between an international community of mathematics educators and the prospective teachers' local learning community. Data from two surveys and from the prospective teachers' reflective journals show that this intervention encouraged prospective teachers to examine and evaluate their own beliefs.

Mathematics textbooks: Messages to students and teachers 87528 downloads
Mal Shield

The set textbook has a strong influence on what takes place in the mathematics classroom, especially at the secondary level. This paper reports on the preliminary stage of a project aimed at developing more effective textbook presentations. In this phase of the project, textbooks are being examined to identify the types of messages about mathematics and its teaching and learning inherent in their presentations and to identify the sources of the underlying messages.

Problem Solving Through Problem Posing: The Experience of Two Teacher Education Students 87534 downloads
Beth Southwell

Teacher education students in their flrst year of university were invited to take part in an eight week program involving solving problems and posing problems on the basis of the given problem. Data concerning two of the eight students who agreed to participate, have been reported in terms of their problem solving strategies, their progress in problem solving skills and their expressions of cognitive and affective factors related to the study. It was found that the requirement to pose a similar problem to a given problem helped clarify thinking and that other important factors were the realism of the problem, the capability for visualisation and the nature and speed of feedback.

Teachers building number sense amid the challenges of change: Some case studies 87529 downloads
Len Sparrow & Alistair McIntosh

The paper describes some preliminary findings from a project in which teachers from two primary schools were observed over one school term as they implemented their own plans for encouraging number sense in their classrooms. Ownership of the entire project was invested in the teachers involved. Comment is made on some of the impediments to change and on one teacher as she implements mental computation activities.

The invisible wall project on problem solving processes: Concepts and methods of interpretive work with high-resolution data 87528 downloads
Martin Stein

The project pupils work on problems with a goal which cannot be reached ("invisible wall project") analyses problem solving processes of children in grades 3-4 and 7-8. So far, we have described basic components of problem solving abilities by using interpretive methods. We now want to apply statistical methods, e.g., for comparing abilities of younger/older children. Consequently, we have complemented the qualitative interpretive methods by quantitative methods. The paper describes the methodological background of both sides of the project.

The incidence of misconceptions of decimal notation amongst students in Grades 5 to 10 87529 downloads
Vicki Steinle and Kaye Stacey

This paper reports the results of a test of decimal understanding based on choosing the larger number from pairs of decimals. Ten incorrect ways of thinking about decimal notation are described. The testing of 2517 students from Grade 5 to Year 10 enables reporting of the incidence of misconceptions according to both a primary and a refined classification. Some variations from previously reported results are noted.

Kindergarten Students' Progress in the Count Me In Too Project 87527 downloads
Rita Stewart, Bob Wright and Peter Gould

In 1997. 866 Kindergarten students, including 47 Aboriginals or Torres Strait Islanders. participated in the Count Me In Too Project. Their progress in early arithmetical strategies, forward number word sequences. and numeral identification was examined. Progress was compared with expected syllabus outcomes and it was found that the majority of the students met or exceeded those expectations. Consistent with earlier and smaller-scale studies. many students began the Kindergarten year with relatively high levels of knowledge and there was much diversity in levels.

Task Context and Applications at the Senior Secondary Level 87528 downloads
Gloria Stillman

A qualitative study was conducted to investigate the impact of prior knowledge of task context on students' approaches to applications tasks am the effect of engagement with context on penormance. Prior knowledge mainly enhanced students' understanding of the task having most impact when students constructed a mental picture of the situation. Moderate to high engagement with a task context was not often associated with poor performance. Poor performance was more likely to be associated with no to low engagement. High engagement was not a necessary condition for success as the degree of engagement necessary for success appeared to be task specific.

Different forms of mathematical questions for different purposes: Comparing student responses to similar closed and open-ended questions 87527 downloads
Peter Sullivan, Elizabeth Warren, Paul White, and Stephanus Suwarsono

Responses of Year 8 students to open-ended and closed mathematics questions, which addressed similar aspects of the curriculum, were compared. The responses of the students were examined and the elements of the tasks were listed. In two out of three pairs examined, the closed question was easier for students. In the other, the open-ended task was easier. It seems that closed and open-ended items may contribute productively both to classroom and specific assessment tasks, although their contribution may be different.

Student Choice of Computation Methods 87530 downloads
Paul Swan & Jack Bana

This study was designed to refine an instrument to explore the relationships between students' mental, written and calculator strategies of computation. A theoretical framework for studying the relationships between these three main methods of computation was postulated. This paper describes this model of the computational processes and some preliminary work carried out with middle to upper primary students in Western Australia. In addition, the questions of factors such as access to calculators, emphasis on written algorithms and mental computation influencing choice of computation method are also discussed.

Mathematical misconceptions -- we have an effective method for reducing their incidence but will the improvement persist? 87529 downloads
Philip Swedosh and John Clark

This paper discusses a continuation of the study previously conducted by these authors in which a strategy based on Piaget's notion of cognitive conflict was successfully employed to reduce the incidence of mathematical misconceptions in a group of tertiary students. A question which remained unanswered in the authors' previous study was "Will the improvement persist or have we seen a short term gain which will disappear in time?" The students were tested again one year later to decide this issue.

Dynamic scaffolding and reflective discourse: successful teaching styles observed within a project to teach mathematical thinking skills 87526 downloads
Howard Tanner and Sonia Jones

The mathematical thinking skills project (Tanner & Jones, 1995) reported that classes which followed a course emphasising metacognitive skills were not only more successful than controls in assessments of those skills, but also in assessments of mathematical development. Ethnographic data revealed significant variations in the teaching style from teacher to teacher and was used to classify the teachers into four groups. This paper discusses the teaching styles of the two most successful groups: the "dynamic scaffolders" and the "reflective scaffolders".

A computer environment to encourage versatile understanding of algebraic equations 87528 downloads
Mike Thomas and Diane Hall

Learning algebra is very difficult for many students, and one of the major obstacles identified in the research literature is a 'cognitive gap' presented by equations of the form ax+b=cx+d, which require operation on the variable for solution. In this small-scale, preliminary study we assessed the value of a computer environment which enables students gradually to investigate algebraic expressions and equations. The initial results are very encouraging and suggest that this may be a way to assist students to learn algebra in a versatile way.

Teacher Beliefs About the Learning and Teaching of Mathematics: Some Comparisons 87529 downloads
Danielle Tracey, Bob Perry, & Peter Howard

During the last four years, a survey instrument was administered to 603 primary and 336 secondary teachers in both government and Catholic schools across an urban and a rural school region in New South Wales. This paper reports on comparisons concerning tile espoused beliefs about mathematics, mathematics learning and mathematics teaching of the teacher respondents and demonstrates significant differences between the teachers across the regions, types of school and gender.

Exploring the Impact of CAS in Early Algebra 87529 downloads
David Tynan & Gary Asp

This paper reports on an investigation into the impact of the availability of a hand held computer algebra system (CAS) on student performance and patterns of algebraic thinking. In particular. their performance in a range of symbol manipulation tasks in the early stages of the middle school algebra curriculum is discussed.

Computers are taking mathematics· into the next century: Gender differences in the attitudes of secondary mathematics students to the use of computers 87527 downloads
Colleen Vale

Secondary students who participated in a computer enhanced mathematics program expressed positive attitudes about the use of computers. They viewed computers ~ a source of pleasure, success, relevance and/or power in mathematics. Girls were more likely than boys to qualify their support for the use of computers and more likely to view computers as a source of success in mathematics. Boys were more likely to claim that computers brought pleasure or relevance to mathematics learning.

The Mathematics, Technology and Science Interface: Implementation in the Middle School 87527 downloads
Grady VenviIle, John Malone, John Wallace and Leonie Rennie

The concepts of middle-schooling and curriculum integration were examined in this study, the aim of which was to provide a research base to inform the development and implementation of models of learning in mathematics, technology and science. A number of the case studies of integration conducted with students aged 11 to 15 years are reported, and issues arising from integrated practices are discussed along with their implications for teaching and learning.

Progressing through the van Hiele levels with Cabri-geometre 87527 downloads
.JiIl Vincent

The influence of the dynamic geometry tool, Cabri-geometre, on the learning of geometry was investigated. Twelve Year 7/8 pupils were divided into two groups on the basis of van Hiele pre-tests: Group I, pupils at Level 0 or 1, and Group H, the remaining pupils. Both groups completed six lessons with structured Cabri worksheets then Group II pupils completed several construction tasks, documented by means of Cabri files and tape-recorded conversations. All· pupils increased their van Hiele levels for some or all of the concepts involved.

What is 'meaning' in gender research? 87530 downloads
Margaret Walshaw

This is a paper about girls in mathematics. In it I give an account of a piece of research which I consider to be theoretically adequate for the work that I wanted to conduct about gender. It addresses the complex questions that people who do any research in mathematics education want to understand better: questions about learning and individuality, about thinking, about expertise. It links these with questions of power, control, dependence and change, and in so doing provides a different story about girls in mathematics.

Students' understanding of the concept of a variable 87527 downloads
Elizabeth Warren

This paper explores the use of written tests and semi-structured interviews in ascertaining students' understanding of the concept of a variable. A written algebra test was administered to 379 students and from the results students were selected for a semi-structured interview. The types of questions asked and the medium in which they were asked appeared to influence the responses given. It is conjectured that these issues must be considered when endeavouring to reach a richer understanding of the students' perception of the concept of a variable.

Numeracy Benchmarks for Years 3 and 5: What about Chance and Data? 87528 downloads
.Jane M. Watson

Since January 1997 there has been much debate within Australia on the type of numeracy benchmarks which should apply to children in Years 3 and 5. As well as debate on the breadth and depth of understanding, there has been difficulty in some areas establishing what children actually do know and can do. Although the data included in this report were not collected to answer questions related to numeracy benchmarking, they may help inform the debate about what children in Years 3 and 5 know and can do in the area of chance and data.

"This is a funny game - you can't say who's going to win!": . Three case studies of children's probabilistic thinking 87527 downloads
Jenni Way

Three case studies of children are used to illustrate the variety of strategies employed by children when asked to make probability judgments in several different game contexts. The children's responses ranged from idiosyncratic and intuitive reactions to the deliberate application of proportional reasoning. It was found that certain combinations of variables in the task designs stimulated different mathematical thinking.

Beliefs about the Use of Calculators in an Upper Primary Mathematics Classroom: A Partial Application of the Theory of Planned Behaviour 87527 downloads
Allan White

This study surveyed a sample of teachers (N = 115) with a questionnaire using the theory of planned behaviour (TPB). It examined primary school teacher intentions to allow students to use calculators in the classroom and the influences upon these intentions. Key salient behavioural. normative and control beliefs held by the teachers are analysed and evaluated according to their respective contribution to attitudes, perceptions of influence by the social environment, and perceived behavioural control.

Metacognition within mathematics: A new and practical multi-method approach 87528 downloads
Jeni Wilson

The importance of metacognition for student learning has been widely acknowledged (Biggs, 1987, Birenbaum, 1996, Brown and De Loache, 1983, Pintrich, and De Groot, 1990, Schoenfeld, 1987, Wilson and Wing Jan, in press). But the practicalities associated with teaching for metacognition and monitoring metacognition are not clear. This paper is concerned about the assessability of metacognition within mathematics. It is asserted that unless metacognition can be assessed then it will exist as a theoretically sound construct but never be considered a viable part of the mathematics curriculum.

An Overview of a Research-based Framework for Assessing and Teaching Early Number 87529 downloads
Bob Wright

This paper provides an overview of a research-based framework for assessing and teaching in early number which has been used extensively in research and practice. The framework includes the following aspects: arithmetical strategies, forward and backward number word sequences, numeral identification, base-ten strategies, combining and partitioning, subitising and spatial patterns, temporal sequences, finger patterns, and quinary-based strategies. Five of these aspects are presented in tabular form as stages or levels. Also described are guiding principles for studying early number knowledge.

Language, mathematics and social disadvantage: a Bourdieuian analysis of cultural capital in mathematics education 87527 downloads
Robyn Zevenbergen

What do students need to know if they are to be constructed as effective learners of mathematics? This question provides the stimulus for this paper where the question is rephrased to: "What do students need to know in order to operate in a manner which is acceptable in the mathematics classroom?" Such a question is not without political implications and so needs to be extended to include questions about the consequences of participation in mathematics classroom. It is widely recognised that success in mathematics is not random, but rather falls into quite distinct patterns whereby students from certain social groups are more likely to be successful in the study of mathematics than others. The focus in this paper is the examination of why students from socially disadvantaged backgrounds are less likely than their middle-class peers to be successful in the study of mathematics. The paper uses two key notions. The first is the classroom interaction patterns noted by Lemke (1990) in which students must be conversant to be able to participate effectively. This knowledge becomes a form of cultural capital (Bourdieu, 1983) which can be transfered later to academic success.

Mathematical saturation within workplace contexts 87528 downloads
Robyn Zevenbergen

In this paper I propose that the literature on situated numeracy has an important role in the reconceptualisation of mathematics education in general and workplace learning in particular. There exists a substantive literature which documents the idiosyncratic knowledge and procedures used by participants in situ to resolve tasks. This literature has been powerful in challenging the orthodoxies within the field of mathematics education whereby the power of mathematics comes from its capacity to be applied across a wide range of contexts. However, this situatedness of mathematics must be considered in conjunction with the degree of mathematics employed within a context. To this end, I propose and develop the notion of "mathematical saturation" which permits the breaking of the dichotomy of school-mathematics and non-school mathematics, and in its place proposes a continuum in which the degree of "pure" mathematics is considered to be a critical element. Using the data collected from a number of worksites, it will be argued that situated numeracy challenges notions of transferability but must be considered alongside the degree of formal mathematics which is used within that context.

Short communications 1998 87527 downloads
 
Short Communication (abstract only)
 
Poster (abstract only)
 
Round Table (abstract only)